@uzbyuksalish

Telegram

@uzbyuksalish

en

Establishment of PPP-Based Kindergartens: Over a Half of Entrepreneurs Surveyed See the Selection Process to be Opaque or Biased

 2022-11-30 18:16:47   |     Просмотров: 2773

On 30 November, as part of the Anticorruption Week, a public discussion of preliminary results of the study ‘Assessment of corruption and integrity risk factors in the establishment and operation of preschool education institutions based on public-private partnership’ took place in Tashkent.

The study was conducted by the Anticorruption Laboratory, which has been run by the Nationwide Movement “Yuksalish” since 2020, in partnership with the Anticorruption Agency of Uzbedkistan, and the International Non -Governmental Organization ‘Regional Dialogue’ (Slovenia) Apart from other activities, the study included sociological surveys among different groups of respondents, involved in the process of public-private partnership (413 people) - representatives of district departments of preschool education, khokimiyats, banks, heads of PPP-based preschool educational institutions, and parents in the city of Tashkent, Bukhara, Andijan Samarkand, Surkhandarya, Tashkent and Kashkadarya regions.

Institutional and legal analysis and preliminary results of the survey showed the inefficiency of separate processes and procedures of PPP, which are factors of corruption risks.

Bureaucracy and complexity of documentation

Most groups of respondents consider the preparation of project documentation for PPP-based preschool institutions as too complicated. Specifically, 25% of entrepreneurs called the application procedure complicated, 17% - non-transparent, 10% - highly bureaucratic.

Two-thirds of representatives of district khokimiyats, half of entrepreneurs and every third specialist of the district department of preschool education pointed out to the need to simplify the procedure for preparing and processing an agreement on the organization of a preschool educational institution based on PPP.

Non-transparent competition

More than half of the interviewed entrepreneurs (53%) answered that the selection process is opaque or biased. Every third believes that some tenders are held only for the use of budget funds, and not to achieve the goals in education.

At the same time, almost every fifth respondent from among the specialists of the district khokimiyats and the departments of preschool education believes that entrepreneurs can influence on the results of competitive selection through the provision of personal services to members of the commission, involving authoritative persons or monetary rewards. 22% of entrepreneurs participating in competitive selection are also confident in the availability of tools of influence on the decision of the selection commission.

About 36% of the representatives of district khokimiyats indicated the need to ensure the transparency of the competitive selection, 74% of specialists of the district departments of preschool education offer the introduction of an open information system.
Subsidy delay.

A third of the representatives of district departments of preschool education report on late payment of subsidies under signed agreements. One out of four respondents reported of entrepreneurs who exceeded the real number of children in preschool educational institutions in order to receive additional subsidies. At the same time, every second person notes that in case of delay / absence of subsidies / loans, the private partner does not have guarantees, for example, in the form of compensation / penalties.

Violations and sanctions

68% of representatives of district departments of preschool education are not aware of the sanctions for the state partner in case of violation of the rules of integrity when interacting with an entrepreneur. 73% are not aware if there are similar sanctions for entrepreneurs.

A third of respondents from among representatives of district khokimiyats claim that in organizing the activities of preschool educational institutions on the basis of PPP, a private entrepreneur violates reporting requirements. 27% of hokimiyat employees and 58% of banks believe that entrepreneurs have financial irregularities.

47% of representatives of district departments of preschool education believe that entrepreneurs are not competent in pedagogy, 42% - in the organization of financial activities, 36% -  in personnel policy. A third of representatives of the district departments of preschool education is sure that entrepreneurs violate ethical norms, every fifth - that businessmen do not have sufficient managerial skills.

The results of the study with recommendations for reducing identified risks were presented to key process players. Experts on anti -corruption strategies and the methodology for evaluating corruption risks told about latest trend in combating corruption. It is proposed to work together to work out the identified factors of corruption risks to reduce them and increase the efficiency of projects based on PPP.

Based on the results, it was noted that recommendations for amendments to the current legislation related to a decrease in corruption risks will be submitted to the Ministry of Preschool Education, Agency for Combating Corruption, and the National Council for Combating Corruption.

The event was organized by a Nationwide Movement “Yuksalish” in partnership with the Anticorruption Agency and the International Non -Governmental Organization “Regional Dialogue” (Slovenia).